20/01/07, Margaret Wente, The charitable and the cheap: Which one are you?
Post
The most generous people of all are probably not who you think they are.
A friend of mine in Chicago puts in a lot of time raising money for the theatre. Chicago, she told me, has more than 150 professional or semi-professional theatre companies, all of which depend at least partly on private donations to keep them afloat. I was stunned. Here in Toronto, the theatre capital of Canada, there are maybe a couple of dozen.
Why the huge difference? Chicago is bigger and richer than Toronto, but not that much bigger and richer. It's no more highbrow either, or at least I like to think not.
The difference, I've concluded, is that Chicagoans are far more generous. They have a thriving culture of giving. They figure that if they like the theatre, then they'd better write the cheques. Here in Toronto we figure that somebody else -- maybe the government -- should write the cheques.
On the generosity scale, the Americans lead the world. They make us look pretty chintzy. They give twice as much of their income to charity as we do. If we gave the same percentage of our incomes to charity as the Americans do, the Canadian charitable sector would be richer by more than $9-billion every year.
Fortunately, we do a whole lot better than the Europeans. They're the world's worst cheapskates. (Only four per cent of Swedes give to charity at all.) What explains the generosity gap? The standard answer is that people who expect the state to pay for more (through higher taxes) give less, and vice versa. Social attitudes about the importance of philanthropy are directly related to the value people place on individual initiative and the role of the state.
But the most generous people of all are probably not who you think they are. They aren't the rich. They aren't my well-heeled liberal neighbours in latte-land (the ones who complain about cutbacks to the arts), and they aren't the urban cyclists who hold rallies for the homeless and vote NDP.
The most generous people in North America are the small-town folks who go to church, drive pick-up trucks, are very family-oriented, have average jobs, and probably hate the gun registry. They give away more of their income -- by far -- than anybody else.
The charity gap is driven not by economics but by values. And those values are old-fashioned ones. In the U.S., the value that correlates most highly with giving is religious faith. "Religious people don't give only to the church," says Arthur C. Brooks, an economist at Syracuse University who is an expert on who gives, and how much. "They also make more gifts to secular causes." The people who give away the most of all (3.7 per cent of their income) live in Utah.
These days, people who are religious are also far more likely to be politically conservative. They're the red-state Bushies, or the Albertans who vote Tory blue. Mr. Brooks's new book, Who Really Cares, proves without a doubt that while godless liberals talk the talk, churchgoing conservatives walk the walk. People in the top five Bush states give three times more of their income to charity than people in the top five Kerry states. Conservatives give away more money and volunteer more time to help the poor. They even give more blood. Liberals talk about how we must do more to help the environment and the homeless; conservatives actually help them.
These findings are a little rattling for people who think "compassionate conservatism" is a joke. They are also a little humbling for secular people (such as me) who write a cheque now and then and congratulate ourselves. And they came as a surprise to Mr. Brooks (who is that rare creature in the U.S., an independent voter). "I came into this thinking that people who say they're compassionate, are compassionate," he says. "I found that's not the case."
Mr. Brooks believes that giving isn't just a civic duty, but a spiritual need. Whether you support a theatre or put time in at a soup kitchen, charity helps us connect with something bigger than ourselves. The people who make him angry are the ones who think charity is bad. Yes, there are quite a few. Many of them lurk in major universities. They argue that if something is truly important, the government should do it. Charity, they say, just lets government off the hook, and therefore should be discouraged. Don't count on them to pick you up if you're run over on a downtown street. They'd rather blame the government for letting too many cars on the road.
Here in Canada the correlation between charity and faith is probably not quite as strong as in the U.S. But the correlation with other traditional values is. Our most generous province is Manitoba, where 1 per cent of people's income is donated to charity. The most generous place in Canada may well be a town like Brandon, where life revolves around family and kids and virtually everybody volunteers for something. "This town has a wonderful ability to pull together," says Debbie Arsenault, who runs the local United Way. "All the charities that operate in this community would tell you the same thing."
Recently, a major American TV show decided to subject Mr. Brooks's findings to a real-world test. It got the Salvation Army to station a bell-ringer in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, just outside the Wal-Mart. The Sally Ann put another bell-ringer in San Francisco, just outside Saks. The average income in San Francisco is twice as much as in Sioux Falls. The San Francisco bell-ringer, who encountered twice as many people, collected only half as much money as the one in Sioux Falls. As one city official explained to Mr. Brooks, "We were taught to tithe here, sir."
So what's the least charitable place in Canada? That would be Quebec, where people donate only 0.3 per cent of their income. Quebeckers are far more European in their expectations of the state, and are also the most secular. You want real compassion? Go to Utah. You want lots of theatre? Go to Chicago. You want to get something back? Try giving. It's a good thing.
A friend of mine in Chicago puts in a lot of time raising money for the theatre. Chicago, she told me, has more than 150 professional or semi-professional theatre companies, all of which depend at least partly on private donations to keep them afloat. I was stunned. Here in Toronto, the theatre capital of Canada, there are maybe a couple of dozen.
Why the huge difference? Chicago is bigger and richer than Toronto, but not that much bigger and richer. It's no more highbrow either, or at least I like to think not.
The difference, I've concluded, is that Chicagoans are far more generous. They have a thriving culture of giving. They figure that if they like the theatre, then they'd better write the cheques. Here in Toronto we figure that somebody else -- maybe the government -- should write the cheques.
On the generosity scale, the Americans lead the world. They make us look pretty chintzy. They give twice as much of their income to charity as we do. If we gave the same percentage of our incomes to charity as the Americans do, the Canadian charitable sector would be richer by more than $9-billion every year.
Fortunately, we do a whole lot better than the Europeans. They're the world's worst cheapskates. (Only four per cent of Swedes give to charity at all.) What explains the generosity gap? The standard answer is that people who expect the state to pay for more (through higher taxes) give less, and vice versa. Social attitudes about the importance of philanthropy are directly related to the value people place on individual initiative and the role of the state.
But the most generous people of all are probably not who you think they are. They aren't the rich. They aren't my well-heeled liberal neighbours in latte-land (the ones who complain about cutbacks to the arts), and they aren't the urban cyclists who hold rallies for the homeless and vote NDP.
The most generous people in North America are the small-town folks who go to church, drive pick-up trucks, are very family-oriented, have average jobs, and probably hate the gun registry. They give away more of their income -- by far -- than anybody else.
The charity gap is driven not by economics but by values. And those values are old-fashioned ones. In the U.S., the value that correlates most highly with giving is religious faith. "Religious people don't give only to the church," says Arthur C. Brooks, an economist at Syracuse University who is an expert on who gives, and how much. "They also make more gifts to secular causes." The people who give away the most of all (3.7 per cent of their income) live in Utah.
These days, people who are religious are also far more likely to be politically conservative. They're the red-state Bushies, or the Albertans who vote Tory blue. Mr. Brooks's new book, Who Really Cares, proves without a doubt that while godless liberals talk the talk, churchgoing conservatives walk the walk. People in the top five Bush states give three times more of their income to charity than people in the top five Kerry states. Conservatives give away more money and volunteer more time to help the poor. They even give more blood. Liberals talk about how we must do more to help the environment and the homeless; conservatives actually help them.
These findings are a little rattling for people who think "compassionate conservatism" is a joke. They are also a little humbling for secular people (such as me) who write a cheque now and then and congratulate ourselves. And they came as a surprise to Mr. Brooks (who is that rare creature in the U.S., an independent voter). "I came into this thinking that people who say they're compassionate, are compassionate," he says. "I found that's not the case."
Mr. Brooks believes that giving isn't just a civic duty, but a spiritual need. Whether you support a theatre or put time in at a soup kitchen, charity helps us connect with something bigger than ourselves. The people who make him angry are the ones who think charity is bad. Yes, there are quite a few. Many of them lurk in major universities. They argue that if something is truly important, the government should do it. Charity, they say, just lets government off the hook, and therefore should be discouraged. Don't count on them to pick you up if you're run over on a downtown street. They'd rather blame the government for letting too many cars on the road.
Here in Canada the correlation between charity and faith is probably not quite as strong as in the U.S. But the correlation with other traditional values is. Our most generous province is Manitoba, where 1 per cent of people's income is donated to charity. The most generous place in Canada may well be a town like Brandon, where life revolves around family and kids and virtually everybody volunteers for something. "This town has a wonderful ability to pull together," says Debbie Arsenault, who runs the local United Way. "All the charities that operate in this community would tell you the same thing."
Recently, a major American TV show decided to subject Mr. Brooks's findings to a real-world test. It got the Salvation Army to station a bell-ringer in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, just outside the Wal-Mart. The Sally Ann put another bell-ringer in San Francisco, just outside Saks. The average income in San Francisco is twice as much as in Sioux Falls. The San Francisco bell-ringer, who encountered twice as many people, collected only half as much money as the one in Sioux Falls. As one city official explained to Mr. Brooks, "We were taught to tithe here, sir."
So what's the least charitable place in Canada? That would be Quebec, where people donate only 0.3 per cent of their income. Quebeckers are far more European in their expectations of the state, and are also the most secular. You want real compassion? Go to Utah. You want lots of theatre? Go to Chicago. You want to get something back? Try giving. It's a good thing.
Home